The unwieldy iPad: It just doesn’t fit in my life, either

Earlier this week on GigaOm, Kevin C. Tofel voiced a conclusion I reached last year, after I tried out an iPad for a month: Tablets are definitely not one-size-fits-all. I, too, expect my mobile devices to be truly mobile by being easily portable — and the size and weight of the iPad doesn’t work for me.

THE BEST TABLET IS THE ONE YOU HAVE WITH YOU

The Tab is roughly the same size as, but thicker than Amazon’s Kindle, which ironically I sold when I got my iPad. Prior to iPad ownership, my Kindle would go everywhere with me because of its small size, light weight, stellar battery life and integrated connectivity. And I do mean everywhere: the device would fit in my jacket pocket or could be thrown — figuratively, not literally — in the car or in a gear bag. The Galaxy Tab offers me that same level of portability, while the iPad doesn’t.

Read: Why I Just Dumped the iPad (Hint: Size Matters)

…What’s intriguing for me, since I blog for CNN Tech, is the overall civility and engagement expressed in the comments here. Yes, there are a few fanboys and flamers, but generally it’s pretty civil — and Tofel is participating constructively.

Meanwhile, on CNN, I’m sure that a post which critiqued such a popular product would have generated an immediate torrent of vicious personal slurs — toward the author, and toward other commenters. And if the author was female, the sexual innuendo and sexist comments would be out in force.

I’m not knocking CNN Tech. I’m just saying it’s interesting to see the cultural difference from one venue to another.

Hat tip to Steve Yelvington for pointing to the GigaOm article.

2 thoughts on The unwieldy iPad: It just doesn’t fit in my life, either

  1. Amy, you’re spot on about two things IMO: the limited relative portability of the iPad compared to smaller devices and the risk of an article on this topic degrading to a fanboi war. 😉 Luckily, it hasn’t devolved into an iOS vs Android conversation because that’s really not what the post is about. Thanks!

    kct

  2. Thanks, Kevin. As a fellow tech reporter/blogger, in my experience it generally doesn’t matter what a post is “about” — if it touches on any fanboi topics, it’s an instant flame war in most venues. GigaOm seems to draw a better crowd.

    – Amy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *